Sun Valley legal dispute ongoing
PROTECTED CONTENT
If you’re a current subscriber, log in below. If you would like to subscribe, please click the subscribe tab above.
Username and Password Help
Please enter your email and we will send you a password reset link.
A prolonged dispute between the Sun Valley Iowa Lake Association (SVILA) and a property owner at the lake has resulted in a significant judgment against the owner.
According to a report from the Des Moines Register, owner Joe Romare has been ordered to pay legal fees totaling approximately $700,000 in legal fees incurred by the SVILA in a battle to collect $1,100 in home owners association dues.
The litigation spanned several months dating back to 2023 when SVLIA claimed Romare had accrued a number of fines related to violations of boating regulations along with non-payment of association dues.
On June 12, 2023, SVILA filed a petition in Ringgold County district court against Romare. In an amended petition filed July 3, 2023, SVILA alleged Romare is “trespassing on Sun Valley Lake by using the lake without complying with SVILA rules. SVILA seeks money damages for the breach of contract and trespass.”
On October 2, 2023, the court denied SVILA’s request for a temporary injunction barring Romare from the use of the lake.
A ruling filed May 23, 2024, found Romare’s property came under jurisdiction of covenants established by SVILA.
Romare’s attorneys continued to file motions asking for the court to reconsider previous judgments regarding the designation of Sun Valley as a private lake.
The dispute eventually went to a jury trial in Ringgold County district court in October 2024.
In its verdict, the jury dismissed SVILA’s claim for boating violations but upheld its claim for payment of back dues.
In the succeeding months, Romare’s attorneys continued to file motion after motion challenging different aspects of the court’s decision. Each motion required SVILA’s attorneys to respond, and fees continued to mount.
In May 2025, district court judge Elizabeth Reynoldson ruled that Romare is liable for SVILA’s legal fees resulting from the continued litigation, after which Romare’s attorneys filed a motion “for judgment notswithstanding the verdict,” in other words, a request for a judge to overturn a jury’s verdict.
A hearing on that motion is set for June 23 in Ringgold County district court.
